“Appeal rights” sounds like fine print until the day you actually need it. For public charter families, that day tends to arrive in one of two very different forms: the school itself is fighting a non-renewal or revocation decision, as KIPP North Philadelphia is doing right now, or your own child is facing a suspension or expulsion.
The process, the timeline, and who gets to appeal are completely different in each case, so it helps to know which one you’re dealing with.
In plain terms, if a school you’re enrolled in loses a renewal vote and appeals, your child’s seat does not disappear the next day.
Start with the school level.
When our local school board votes not to renew a public charter or to revoke one, state law requires 30 days of public comment before that decision becomes final, following a public hearing the board must give adequate notice of in advance.
If the board’s decision stands, the public charter school can appeal to the state Charter Appeal Board, which reviews the school’s charter plan, annual reports, student performance data, and community support before ruling.
Here is the part most families don’t know and probably need to: the original charter agreement stays in effect while that appeal is pending, unless there is a serious risk to student or staff safety. In plain terms, if a school you’re enrolled in loses a renewal vote and appeals, your child’s seat does not disappear the next day.
If the Charter Appeal Board rules in the school’s favor, the revocation is undone. If it upholds the board, the school closes and its assets are distributed to the schools that go on to serve its former students.
Now for the student level, which works on its own separate clock.
For a short suspension of ten school days or fewer, your child is entitled to an informal hearing where they can speak and present evidence.
Once exclusion reaches ten consecutive school days, meaning an expulsion is on the table, the protections expand significantly: the right to an attorney, the right to know who the witnesses against your child are, the right to cross examine them, the right to record the hearing, and the right to request that it be held publicly.
After an expulsion decision, families keep the right to appeal in court, and a child under 17 keeps a right to continued education even after being expelled.
Pennsylvania’s published discipline guidance is written with district schools in mind and doesn’t call out charter schools by name, but charter schools operate under the same state School Code, and as we covered in our earlier rights explainer, families are entitled to the same due process options available at any public school.
What to actually do with all of this:
- Keep every written notice a school sends you, and put your own concerns in writing back to the school so there’s a paper trail.
- Track the two clocks that matter most, the ten school day mark that triggers formal hearing rights for a student, and the 30 day public comment window before a renewal decision becomes final.
If you’re not sure where you stand, the Education Law Center offers free guidance to Philadelphia families navigating exactly these situations.