The Center for Education Reform’s (CER) 2026 National Charter School Law Rankings & Scorecard gives Pennsylvania a grade of C- and a score of 72 out of 100, ranking the state 31st among the 48 states with charter school laws — a one-spot drop from 30th in CER’s 2025 rankings.
CER breaks its state scores into sub-categories. Pennsylvania posted its strongest marks on charter cap policy, scoring 9 out of 10, and on operating funds, scoring 7 out of 10.
It scored 5 out of 8 on school autonomy and 5 out of 7 on freedom to innovate. Its weakest scores came on independence of local and state authority, 2 out of 7, and on two categories where the state received no points at all: facilities funding, 0 out of 5, and authorizer activity, 0 out of 3.
“With the number of students and parents who are enrolled in charters, it’s time for some much needed reform to ensure the best possible outcomes for students,” said Tony Payton Jr., a former Pennsylvania state representative who now works as a lobbyist on education issues. “Ensuring we have some changes around authorization is essential and facilities funding is overdue.”
For families, the low scores translate into two concrete gaps. A facilities funding score of 0 out of 5 means Pennsylvania, unlike some other states, provides charter schools no dedicated public funding stream to buy, build or maintain school buildings — costs that instead come out of the same per-pupil dollars that would otherwise pay for teachers, materials and programs.
An authorizer activity score of 0 out of 3, paired with a low score on independence of local and state authority, points to the fact that the School District of Philadelphia both authorizes charter schools and operates its own schools that compete with them for students — the same conflict of interest PCE has raised in its push for an independent charter authorization board.
It’s a debate playing out largely in testimony and hearings, which is why PCE has said parent, student and teacher voices carry particular weight in it: they are the ones who can describe, in specifics lawmakers don’t otherwise hear, what a funding gap or an authorization fight means for a classroom.
Pennsylvania’s zero scores on facilities funding and authorizer activity, along with its low mark on independence of local and state authority, track two of Philadelphia Charters for Excellence’s longstanding legislative priorities: securing dedicated facilities funding for charter schools and establishing an independent charter authorization board separate from the School District of Philadelphia.
PCE has pushed for both changes in Harrisburg and before City Council. Whether the 2026 scorecard itself moves any votes this legislative cycle is not yet known — as of this writing, no bill tied directly to the report has been introduced, and The Charter Record is not aware of a floor vote scheduled on either facilities funding or an independent charter authorizer.
PCE has said the data will factor into its ongoing advocacy, including its annual Legislative Scorecard.
CER’s full narrative analysis and methodology notes for Pennsylvania’s ranking were not available in the material reviewed for this article.
The Charter Record will continue to track how, if at all, it shapes this legislative session.