Board of Education Remains Silent on Project RiSE at 9/24 Meeting

Philadelphia’s Charter Schools Office (CSO) says pending litigation prevents it from updating the public on its overhaul of the evaluation framework for public charter schools. Charter leaders told the Board of Education the silence leaves thousands of families without answers.

Philadelphia’s Board of Education held an Action Meeting on September 24, 2026. The meeting was anticipated by the charter sector as an opportunity to learn updates about Project RiSE, an effort by the School District to revise and reimagine the existing charter evaluation framework.

“Unfortunately, because of various ongoing legal matters, we are not currently able to provide updates,” Peng Chao, the District’s Chief of Charter Schools, wrote in a Sept. 23 email to charter school leaders.

Chao wrote that work on the project continues, but that “it is appropriate for the CSO to refrain from public comment at this time.” He had previously told the RiSE Working Group that the office would provide periodic updates, including at the September meeting. The email did not say which legal matters it referred to or when updates would resume.

Despite not appearing as an official agenda item, tensions about RiSE were largely present at 440 N Broad St. Five testimonies, four spoken and one written, were entered into the record by charter leaders Dr. Cassandra St. Vil (PCE), Dr. Alberta O’Brien (Community Academy of Philadelphia Charter School), Dr. Margery Covello (Lindley Academy Charter School), Amy Hollister (PCE), and Christopher Zagacki (New Foundations Charter School).

St. Vil stated, “This is not accountability. This is an experiment being run on the backs of children, and it must end.” 

“Schools with similar results receive different outcomes, leaving communities without a clear explanation of why,” Covello said.

Each of the charter leader testimonies pressed the same concerns with the CSO’s lack of transparency, several citing a previous willingness to participate in the project’s working groups earlier this year. Zagacki wrote, “I feel like my voice and the voice of the sector has been shut out of the next steps.”

Covello and O’Brien both also noted that they have their schools’ 2025-2026 PSSA data and have been using it to plan “positive academic outcomes for our students.” Earlier in the meeting, Superintendent Dr. Tony Watlington noted that PSSA data was still not available but would be released upon clearance from the Pennsylvania Department of Education. 

A middle school student from Science Leadership Academy called the District “equally responsible” for the lack of available test scores. Philly’s eighth graders begin the school selection process on October 5, on a delayed timeline due to missing test scores.

The Board Meeting also featured a heavy presence by community members and district staff members in opposition to the proposed closure of Lankenau, overcrowded classrooms at Girls High, and heating/cooling issues at several school sites.

You May Also Like