Charter Schools and Philadelphia’s School District Both Say They’re Underfunded. Here’s What the Money Actually Shows

Charter dollars and district dollars come from the same $4.6 billion pool that funds every Philadelphia public school — but the money doesn’t move the same way for every cost, especially when it comes to buildings.

Charter dollars and district dollars come from the same $4.6 billion pool that funds every Philadelphia public school — but the money doesn’t move the same way for every cost, especially when it comes to buildings.

Ask a Philadelphia parent whether charter schools “take money” from the School District of Philadelphia, and you’ll get a confident yes almost as often as a confident no. Both answers are half right.

Philadelphia’s public schools — district and charter combined — run on roughly $4.6 billion a year, with about $2 billion coming from city and other local sources and most of the rest from the state.

The District enrolls about 113,000 students across 213 district-run schools; another 65,000 attend the city’s 81 public charter schools, or roughly one in three of the city’s public school students.

How the Money Follows the Student

Charter schools don’t receive a separate pot of money from Harrisburg or City Hall. Under Pennsylvania’s 1997 charter school law, funding follows the student: when a family enrolls a child in a charter, the district that child would otherwise attend sends that charter a per-student payment, calculated from the district’s own prior-year spending.

In Philadelphia, that has worked out to roughly $11,500 per regular-education student and more than $36,000 per special-education student in recent years — figures that vary district to district statewide, since the formula uses each district’s own costs as its baseline.

The formula excludes several categories of district spending on the theory that charters don’t incur them the same way: adult education, transportation, facility construction and debt service, services to nonpublic-school students, and most federal aid, which charters can apply for directly.

Charter advocates point to those exclusions as the reason charters operate, by their estimate, on 70 to 75 percent of what a district school receives per student.

The Facilities Gap

Facilities are where that exclusion is most absolute. State law doesn’t just discount building costs from the charter payment formula — it removes them entirely, which means Pennsylvania charter schools receive $0 in dedicated per-pupil facilities funding through the state-mandated formula that pays for everything else.

Charters cover building costs out of their operating budgets, private loans, bond financing without a state guarantee behind it, or fundraising.

By the Center for Education Reform’s national scorecard of state charter school laws, Pennsylvania’s law earned an overall C in the 2024 edition and slipped to a C- in CER’s August 2026 update, with facilities funding remaining one of the law’s weakest components in both editions: CER’s 2024 breakdown scored it just 0.5 of 5 possible points in that category.

CER grades state law, not individual cities, so the rating describes Pennsylvania’s charter statute as a whole rather than Philadelphia specifically.

Does Charter Funding “Take” From the District?

The belief that charters “take” money treats district and charter funding as two competing pots.

Structurally, they’re the same pot — every dollar in the formula was already earmarked for whichever public school a given student attends.

And the belief only applies at all to a student who would otherwise have filled a district seat: roughly 30 percent of Philadelphia’s charter students never attended a district school in the first place, so three in ten charter enrollments aren’t diverting an existing student, or the dollar tied to one, away from the district.

For the other 70 percent, the belief holds real truth once a student actually leaves a district school: that student’s per-pupil revenue goes with them, while costs like heating a half-empty building, or a teacher whose class shrinks from 28 students to 24, don’t fall by the same share right away. Researchers call this a “stranded cost,” and it’s the most-studied part of the charter funding debate nationally.

“Typically, at least in the short and even the medium term, public schools can’t cut costs commensurate with the amount of revenue that they’re losing,” Robert Bifulco, a Syracuse University public administration professor who studies charter school finance, told Chalkbeat in 2019.

A 2017 financial analysis commissioned by the School District of Philadelphia and conducted by the consulting firm Afton Partners put a number on that gap locally: it estimated the added cost of each additional charter student at roughly $4,824 when debt service was excluded, or about $6,898 when it was included; below the district’s earlier estimate of $7,000 per seat, but not zero.

That same analysis found the gap narrows over time and shrinks sharply when districts consolidate underused buildings — a current goal championed by Superintendent Tony Watlington. Afton estimated that closing schools running below half capacity could cut Philadelphia’s stranded costs by more than half.

Charter advocates argue the more relevant question isn’t whether charters cost the district money, but whether Philadelphia families who can’t afford to move to a better-resourced district or pay private tuition should have a voice in public school options at all.

In an op-ed in the Inquirer David Hardy, president of Girard College, and founder of Boys Latin of Philadelphia writes “Instead of complaining about stranded costs, districts should be worried about the students who choose charters to avoid being “stranded” in failing public schools.

He goes on further stating “Having founded and run a charter school for 10 years, I acknowledge that there are costs to the district when students choose charters. But the opportunity costs for the children involved are far greater than the stranded costs that generate such intense public debate.”

You May Also Like