Amid District School Closure Debate, Charter Schools Become Flashpoint for Board Critics

Although only two items on the October 29 School Board meeting agenda concerned charter schools, the sector became a major topic of discussion on Thursday evening.

The two charter-related voting items were an amendment changing the location of Young Scholars Charter School and a charter renewal for Harambee Institute of Science and Technology Charter School. Both items passed, the Harambee renewal unanimously. Board President Reginald Streater cast the only “no” vote on the Young Scholars amendment.

The meeting opened with a drumline performance by students from Universal Institute Charter School. Robin Cooper, president of the Commonwealth Association of School Administrators (CASA), later cited the performance during public testimony as an example of what she described as the Board’s favoritism toward charter schools. Cooper closed her testimony by saying, “If you are not going to represent our public schools, I am asking you to put your resignation letters in tonight.”

Philadelphia’s 84 brick-and-mortar charter schools are public schools, authorized by the Board of Education and overseen by the District’s Charter Schools Office.

The meeting ran more than an hour past its scheduled end, with much of the testimony focused on the District’s Facilities Master Plan, which proposes closing 17 schools and modernizing 169 others. Students, teachers, and community members from Lankenau, Parkway Northwest, Paul Robeson, and Overbrook Elementary testified in opposition to the plan.

City Councilmember Isaiah Thomas, chair of Council’s education committee, also spoke against the proposed closures and called on Mayor Cherelle Parker to step in and revise the plan. Thomas had attended a rally alongside Stand Up for Philly Schools, the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, CASA, and SDP families and students prior to the meeting. Earlier this year, Parker penned an op-ed with Superintendent Dr. Watlington about the importance of the Facilities Plan. 

Other speakers raised concerns about equity and transparency in the plan. Councilmember Jeffery Young, Jr., said closures disproportionately affect Black and Brown children, and contrasted them with what he described as the Board’s willingness to open charter schools “without batting an eye.” Early College Charter School of Philadelphia opened this year as the first new charter school in the city in nearly a decade. According to the District’s demographic data from the 2025-26 school year, 85% of Philadelphia brick-and-mortar charter school students identify as students of color. 

Several speakers from the charter sector also testified. Amanda Wilson, executive director of Philadelphia Montessori Charter School, described growth and student engagement at her school. A PMCS teacher and parents from Belmont Charter School spoke similarly about their schools, emphasizing the sense of belonging and support students and families feel there.

Mariel Ziegler, interim chief of the Charter Schools Office, gave a presentation to the Board. The presentation did not include updates on Project RiSE, which is scheduled to to be piloted at the start of the 2027-28 school year. 

As of October 30, the Charter Schools Office’s website includes the following note: “Work on Project RiSE continues, but we believe it is appropriate for the CSO to refrain from public comment at this time.”

You May Also Like