Charter Group Calls on School Board to Halt Charter Renewals

PCE says the Board’s own reform effort, Project RiSE, used to decide charter renewals is broken, and shouldn’t be used to close schools.

PCE says the Board’s own reform effort, Project RiSE, is a tacit admission that the scoring system used to decide charter renewals is broken, and that it shouldn’t be used to close schools while a replacement is still years away.


Philadelphia Charters for Excellence (PCE) called on the Philadelphia Board of Education May 11 to stop issuing adverse charter renewal decisions until Project RiSE, the Board’s own initiative to overhaul how it evaluates charter schools, is finished and formally adopted.

The Board has used its Charter School Performance Framework to assess charter schools since 2012. It launched Project RiSE in October 2024 to reform that framework, but the updated version is not expected to be piloted until the 2027-2028 school year.

This means the current system would remain in place through at least two more renewal cycles unless the Board pauses adverse decisions in the meantime.

PCE points to an exchange during the 2024-2025 renewal hearings as evidence the existing framework is flawed. Board President Reginald Streater asked the District’s Charter Schools Office whether a school could post zero percent proficiency and still meet standards under the current scoring system.

The answer, according to PCE, was yes — an exchange the organization calls proof of “a fundamental flaw” in how charter performance is currently measured.

PCE also cites a 2023 independent legal review by the law firm Ballard Spahr, which found that the School District of Philadelphia has a structural conflict of interest: it operates its own schools while simultaneously serving as the sole judge of whether charter schools may continue operating.

PCE says that conflict shapes every renewal decision the Board makes under the current framework.

PCE is asking the Board to take two specific steps: cease adverse renewal decisions until Project RiSE is finalized and adopted, and commit publicly to a timeline for completing RiSE with transparency at each phase.

The organization separately renewed its call for the City of Philadelphia to pursue an independent charter authorization process, which would remove the School District from its dual role as charter operator and charter judge.

“Public charter school families have made a clear choice about where best to educate their children,” said Dr. Cassandra St. Vil, PCE’s CEO, in the organization’s statement. “They deserve a renewal process that is honest, consistent, not one the Board has already acknowledged is broken. Pausing these decisions is not a retreat from accountability. It is what accountability actually looks like.”

PCE represents 70 public charter schools serving approximately 65,000 students — nearly two in five Philadelphia public school students, by the organization’s count. The Board of Education had not publicly responded to PCE’s request as of publication.

The Charter Record will continue to track Project RiSE’s timeline and any Board action on pending renewals.

You May Also Like