Q&A with PCE’s David Rossi on Independent Authorization

Philadelphia’s Board of Education runs the District’s schools. It also decides whether public charter schools open, expand, renew, or close. Philadelphia Charters for Excellence (PCE) says that overlap is a structural conflict of interest and wants an independent authorizer instead. PCE is pursuing the change through a legislative framework aimed at the 2027 session and, separately, through a lawsuit against the District. The Charter Record asked PCE Policy Director David Rossi why now, what the Ballard Spahr findings mean, and what would change for families.

Disclosure: The Charter Record is funded by PCE, and Mr. Rossi speaks for the organization. Independent review of this Q&A was conducted according to Charter Record policy.


What is independent authorization? And what would it mean for Philadelphia families?

Independent authorization means separating the people who operate one group of public schools from the people making major decisions about another group of public schools.

Right now, the Philadelphia Board of Education is responsible for making decisions it believes are best for district schools and district students.

At the same time, that same Board makes major decisions about public charter schools and charter students. The conflict is built into the structure. It asks the Board to carry two different responsibilities at the same time.

This is not about questioning the intentions of individual Board members. It is about creating a structure that families can trust.

For parents, these are not abstract policy decisions. They affect whether their child’s school can open, expand, renew, or remain open. Families deserve confidence that those decisions are being made fairly, prioritizing the best interests of students first.

Public charter schools are public schools. Every public school student deserves a fair system of accountability.

Why act now instead of waiting for Project RiSE?

For months, PCE and members of Philly’s public charter school leadership participated in working groups to inform Project RiSE because we are all aiming for the current process to improve. 

However, it has not been the collaborative experience we had hoped for, and we remain concerned that the final framework may not address the underlying problem and the inherent conflict of interest that hasn’t been addressed.

Even a better evaluation framework would still leave the same basic structure in place. The District would continue operating one group of public schools while also making major decisions about public charter schools.

And these concerns are not new. The 2023 Ballard Spahr investigation grew out of concerns raised by Black-led charter school leaders about how their schools were being treated. 

The accompanying equity analysis specifically examined the disproportionate closure of Black-led charter schools in Philadelphia.

Families have already waited a long time for a process they can trust. We should continue trying to improve the current system, but we also need to be willing to address the structure itself.

Why does PCE believe independent authorization is the right fix instead of keeping the District as authorizer and adding safeguards?

Safeguards can help. We support clearer standards, greater transparency, and a better process. However, safeguards do not remove the basic conflict.

The District has a responsibility to operate and strengthen its schools. At the same time, it makes decisions about public charter schools that serve many of the same families and are funded from the same pool of public education dollars.

Those responsibilities can come into tension even when everyone involved is acting in good faith. Independent authorization separates those responsibilities.

Fairness matters most when someone is exercising power over decisions that deeply affect other people. Families should be confident that decisions about their child’s school are based on educational quality, student outcomes, financial responsibility, and clear standards.

Does Ballard Spahr’s finding that there was no intentional racial discrimination weaken PCE’s argument?

It actually strengthens it. We should remember why the investigation happened in the first place.

Black-led charter schools raised concerns that they were being treated differently in the authorization and renewal process. The resulting equity analysis specifically examined the disproportionate closure of Black-led charter schools.

The investigation did not find intentional racial discrimination, yet disparities still existed. That is an important finding.

If this were simply a problem of individual intent, then the solution would be to change the individuals. But when a system can produce inequitable outcomes even when people do not intend for that to happen, that tells us the problem is structural.

The report also recognized the importance of understanding the experiences of Black students, families, schools, and communities when evaluating these outcomes. So to me, the finding does not weaken the case for reform. It reinforces it.

Good people can work within a structure that still produces unfair results. Responsible leadership means being willing to change that structure.

District and charter schools still compete for the same funding. What does independent authorization fix that funding reform would not?

Funding reform and authorizing reform solve two different problems. Funding reform is about making sure public education dollars are distributed fairly.

Authorizing reform is about who decides whether a public charter school opens, expands, renews, or closes. We need to address both.

All of these schools are public schools. The question is whether families can be confident that decisions affecting their child’s education are being made based on school quality and what is best for students, rather than being influenced by competing institutional responsibilities.

Independent authorization helps provide that confidence.

If PCE wants to partner with the District, why remove the District from oversight?

We actually believe separating oversight can strengthen the partnership.

Partnership does not require one partner to regulate the other. In fact, when one partner has authority over another, it can make genuine collaboration harder.

The District and public charter schools serve children from the same city and often from the same neighborhoods. We share challenges involving transportation, special education, safety, facilities, enrollment, and many other issues.

There is a great deal we should be working on together.

Removing the regulatory relationship could allow both sides to work together more openly and with greater trust. The goal is not less partnership. We believe this could create better partnership.

D.C.’s Public Charter School Board is still a government agency. How is that really different?

Independent does not mean private or unaccountable. The important distinction in D.C. is that the organization authorizing public charter schools is separate from the organization operating traditional public schools.

That is the principle that matters.

Philadelphia does not need to copy another city exactly. We need a structure that works for Philadelphia and Pennsylvania law. But the authorizing process should be public, transparent, accountable, and separate from the competing responsibility of operating another group of public schools.

Is the real goal faster charter growth?

No. The goal is not charter growth for the sake of growth. The goal is making sure every child in Philadelphia has access to a great public education.

For too long, educational opportunity has often been connected to who a child is and where a child lives. Families should not have to accept that their address determines the quality of education available to their child.

Public charter schools became part of Pennsylvania’s education landscape in 1997, nearly thirty years ago, because families wanted additional choices and  demanded a need for new approaches to serving students. 

Ongoing interest and long waitlists show us that public charter schools are here to stay, and that they are  especially important in Philadelphia. Public charter schools serve many children living in poverty and many children from racial and ethnic communities that have historically been underserved.

Choice is part of the solution for families that want better for their students, but choice itself is not the goal. The goal is excellent public school opportunities for every child.

If a strong public school can responsibly serve more children whose families want to attend, there should be a fair process for considering that. And if a school is not serving children well, it should be held accountable.

What matters is what is best for students and families.

What does a surrender clause actually require a school to give up?

A surrender clause can require a public charter school to give up legal rights it would otherwise have, particularly the right to appeal certain future decisions.

In simple terms, a school can be asked to give up part of its right to challenge a future government decision as a condition of getting its charter renewed today.

We do not believe a public school should have to surrender basic due process rights in order to continue serving its students.

Our current legislative proposal would prohibit surrender clauses and the waiver of statutory appeal rights.

Have Philadelphia schools actually been able to gather the 1,000 signatures required to appeal?

Yes. Many schools have been able to gather the signatures. But that misses the point.

The question is why a public school should have to organize a petition campaign simply to exercise its right to an appeal.

Due process, a fundamental principle of American law, should not depend on whether a school can collect 1,000 signatures.

If a government decision deserves review, the appeal should be decided on the merits. That is why our proposal eliminates the requirement and restores access to appeal based on the substance of the case.

Would independent authorization make it harder to close a poorly performing charter school?

Not at all. Independent authorization should make accountability clearer and more credible.

Children only get one chance at each year of their education. If a school is consistently failing to serve students well, we have a responsibility to act.

Schools should be evaluated against clear academic, financial, and operational standards. If a school does not meet those standards, the authorizer should take appropriate action.

What independence changes is confidence in the decision.

When you remove the structural conflict, families, schools, and the public can have greater confidence that a decision to renew, intervene, or close a school is based on evidence and on what is best for children.

Accountability is not the opposite of fairness. A fair system should make accountability stronger.

Charter reform has faced political opposition in the past. What is different politically now?

What has changed is that we now have more experience with the current system, more evidence about its limitations, and a much clearer proposal for how to improve it.

We also have an opportunity to move the conversation beyond the old debate of charter schools versus district schools.

Families who choose public charter schools in Philadelphia come from many different backgrounds and hold many different political views. Their decision about where to send their child is usually not political. It is deeply personal.

They want a school where their child can learn, be safe, be challenged, be cared for, and have an opportunity to succeed. That is where this conversation should begin.

Our job is to help policymakers understand that authorizing reform is about fairness, accountability, and good governance within public education.

Has a bill actually been introduced? What is the realistic timeline?

Not yet. We now have a detailed legislative framework that is prepared for the drafting process. The next steps are working with legislators, refining the language, identifying sponsors, and building support.

Our current strategy is focused on preparing legislation for the 2027 legislative session.This is important enough to do carefully.

Our goal is to create a policy that can earn support, work in practice, and create a system that families can trust for years to come.

With authorizing reform as you’ve described it, what would actually change for a family enrolling a child next fall?

For most parents, the daily experience would probably look very similar. They would still choose a school, apply, enroll their child, and send that child to school every morning. What would change is their confidence in the system behind those decisions.

Parents could have greater confidence that decisions about whether their school opens, expands, renews, or closes are being made through a fair process and with the best interests of children at the center.

Families place tremendous trust in a school when they send their child through its doors every morning.

Our public education system should honor that trust.

Parents should be able to believe that decisions affecting their child’s education are being driven by educational quality and what students need, not by institutional priorities that have little to do with whether their child is receiving a great education.

What would you personally consider success?

Passing legislation would be important, but that would not be the ultimate measure of success. Success is when families trust the system.

It is when a strong public school has a fair opportunity to serve children whose families want to attend. It is when a struggling school clearly understands what it needs to improve.It is when a school that consistently fails children is held accountable through a process the public can trust. 

Most importantly, success is when more children in Philadelphia have access to an excellent public education.

Families don’t have time to wait for a system’s fancy five-year plan every five years. Children get one childhood and one opportunity to receive the education that prepares them for what comes next. 

That is what all of this should ultimately be about. For too long and too often, “the system” has vested interests that create barriers to all students receiving a great education. Success is educational systems, political structures, districts, schools and all adults working together to do what is best for kids. 

Anything else you would like readers to know?

I think it is important to remember who this conversation is really about. It is not primarily about public charter schools. It is not primarily about the School District. It is about children and families.

Charter schools are public schools. They became an important part of Philadelphia’s education landscape because families needed more options and because our public education system needed new ways to meet the needs of children.

For too many generations, educational opportunity in Philadelphia has been unequal.

A child’s racial background, neighborhood, or family income should never determine the quality of education available to that child.

Many of the families served by Philadelphia’s public charter schools come from communities that have been overlooked or underserved for far too long. Those families deserve to be heard. They deserve meaningful choices, and they deserve a public education system that respects the decisions they make for their children.

Choice alone will not solve every problem in public education. But choice needs to be part of Philadelphia’s education landscape.

We need excellent district schools. We need excellent public charter schools. We need real accountability for every school. And we need a system that is willing to change when it is not serving children as well or as fairly as it should.

Authorizing reform is not about making things easier for public charter schools.

It is about creating a public education system that is fair, accountable, compassionate, and worthy of the trust families place in it every day.

Note: As of publication, PCE has declined to comment on the pending lawsuit, per its policy on active litigation.

You May Also Like