Charter Schools and Philadelphia’s School District Both Say They’re Underfunded. Here’s What the Money Actually Shows

Charter dollars and district dollars come from the same $4.6 billion pool that funds every Philadelphia public school — but the money doesn’t move the same way for every cost, especially when it comes to buildings.

No Fee for the Middleman

One place the district cannot claim a hidden cost: processing the payment itself. Nothing in the 1997 charter law, or in the state Department of Education’s own guidance on charter funding, authorizes a school district to deduct an administrative or processing fee before paying a charter school.

The law requires the full, formula-calculated amount to be paid out in twelve equal monthly installments. If a district falls behind, a charter school can ask the state to redirect the district’s own basic education subsidy check straight to the charter instead — bypassing the district entirely. There is no toll booth built into this system.

By the Numbers

How a per-pupil dollar splits between a Philadelphia district school and a Philadelphia charter school:

Funding componentDistrict schoolCharter school
Base per-pupil instructional funding (state + local)Kept by districtFollows student, paid through district
Special education add-onKept by districtFollows student, paid through district
TransportationDistrict provides directlyNot in per-pupil rate
Facilities
(construction, debt service)
Funded via local taxes, capital budget, debt$0 from formula; self-funded
Adult educationDistrict onlyExcluded
Services to nonpublic-school studentsDistrict onlyExcluded
Most federal aidReceived directlyApplied for directly, not through district
District administrative/
processing fee
N/ANone permitted by law

Philadelphia’s current per-pupil charter rates

Student typePhiladelphia charter per-pupil rate (2023-24)
Regular education≈ $11,500
Special education$36,000+

Statewide, regular-education rates range from about $6,600 to over $17,000 and special-education rates from about $13,000 to over $43,000, since each district’s own prior-year spending sets its own rate.

A Bigger Fight Over a Shrinking Pie

Much of the friction between Philadelphia’s district and its charter schools traces back to a bigger fight neither side controls: how little Pennsylvania sends to low-wealth school districts in the first place.

In February 2023, Commonwealth Court Judge Renée Cohn Jubelirer ruled that Pennsylvania’s school funding system violates the state constitution, finding that the state’s heavy reliance on local property taxes systematically shortchanges low-wealth districts. Neither the state nor the district appealed, letting the ruling stand.

A bipartisan Basic Education Funding Commission convened in response and, in January 2024, recommended the state phase in $5.4 billion in new funding over seven years, including a mandatory $200 million annual increase, to close the gap statewide.

“It’s no secret” that Philadelphia schools have “suffered for years for historic underfunding,” Superintendent Tony B. Watlington Sr. said in June 2025, as he and Philadelphia Federation of Teachers President Arthur Steinberg jointly pressed state lawmakers for more funding.

That underfunding is a state-level problem, but it collides with a Philadelphia-specific one: the School District, unlike most Pennsylvania districts, has no power to set its own tax rates and depends entirely on City Council and the state legislature for revenue.

The city does send substantial money. Of the district’s $4.6 billion FY2025 budget, roughly $2.1 billion came from 16 local taxes, fees, and contributions, according to a City Controller Christy Brady report — led by nearly $1.2 billion in real estate tax revenue, plus a direct $285 million appropriation from City Council’s General Fund, with the state providing about $2 billion and the remainder from federal sources.

Council added to that in June 2026, approving $48 million in one-time funding as the district cut 340 school-based positions to help close its $300 million structural deficit. “There is money, and we put more money on the table,” City Councilmember Isaiah Thomas said at the time.

Watlington and Mayor Cherelle Parker have both said the money isn’t the kind the district can build a budget around: Parker called it a “band-aid” that “doesn’t get to the heart of the matter,” and Watlington said the district “cannot restore the 340 school based positions without a commitment to recurring and predictable funding over multiple years.”

What the Pending Audits Could Show

Two pending audits could add real numbers to that argument, though only one touches charter funding directly.

The special performance audit City Council President Kenyatta Johnson requested — which Controller Brady agreed to conduct, and which Philadelphia Charters for Excellence has publicly backed — will examine the district’s staffing levels, administrative and consultant spending, budgeting practices, and long-term fiscal planning.

Because charter payments are one of the cost drivers the district cites in its deficit, that audit is positioned to show, with real numbers, how much of the deficit is actually attributable to charter tuition growth versus other factors like staffing, healthcare, and pension costs.

Separately, state Sen. Anthony H. Williams asked Pennsylvania Auditor General Timothy L. DeFoor on August 20, 2026, to audit a different question: how the district manages privately raised funds, grants, and philanthropic contributions over the past five years.

Williams’ request doesn’t examine charter payments at all. It’s aimed at whether private money supplements or effectively substitutes for public funding, and whether it’s distributed equitably across district schools. Between the two, only Johnson’s audit is likely to say anything new about the charter funding fight.

“We’ve got to do better.” Hardy says. “Charter or public, the real challenge is to provide high-quality schools so that all children, regardless of their zip code, graduate prepared to succeed in college.”

You May Also Like