If School Facilities Matter, Every Public School Student Deserves Support

Philadelphia’s teachers union has put school facilities at the center of the education debate. Pennsylvania’s charter school students deserve a place in that conversation.

Philadelphia’s teachers union has put school facilities at the center of the education debate. Pennsylvania’s charter school students deserve a place in that conversation.

The Philadelphia Federation of Teachers has made an important point: the condition of school buildings matters. It matters to student learning, school safety, and the decisions families make about where to send their children.

That principle should apply to every public school and every public school student in Philadelphia.

On November 11, the teachers union countered the School District of Philadelphia’s plan to close 17 schools with an alternative proposal. The union is calling for approximately $25 million in initial improvements, arguing that cleaner, safer, better-maintained buildings could help retain students and restore families’ confidence in district schools. The union is also demanding that Mayor Parker intervene to prevent the closures.

PFT President Arthur Steinberg raised concerns that the district’s facilities strategy makes its schools less competitive with charter and cyber school options.

There is an important point embedded in that argument: families have choices, and the quality of school facilities can influence those choices.

But there is another side of Philadelphia’s facilities story that deserves equal attention.

Nearly 40 percent of Philadelphia’s public school students attend charter schools. These students also need safe classrooms, reliable heating and cooling, modern technology, and buildings that support learning.

Yet Pennsylvania’s brick-and-mortar charter schools receive no dedicated, recurring facilities funding through the state’s charter funding formula.

Instead, charter schools must pay for leases, mortgages, building improvements, maintenance, and repairs from operating resources, borrowing, or fundraising. Every dollar devoted to those expenses is a dollar that cannot be used for another educational need.

This is not a small distinction. It is a structural difference in how Pennsylvania supports its public schools.

A June 2026 report by Bellwether, Resource Realities: Understanding Pennsylvania’s District and Charter Funding System, found that brick-and-mortar charter schools receive, on a weighted per-pupil basis, approximately 79 cents in formula funding for every dollar of state and local revenue received by school districts.

The report also highlights the facilities challenges facing charter schools, which generally lack access to the public capital funding and financing mechanisms available to school districts.

The findings raise a straightforward question: Why should the public resources available to support a student’s learning environment depend so heavily on which public school that student attends?

To be clear, the district’s facilities problems are real. Aging buildings, deferred maintenance, and costly repairs cannot be dismissed. The teachers union is right to insist that students deserve buildings that are clean, comfortable, dry, and safe.

Charter students deserve those same conditions.

The fact that charter schools continue to attract families despite their facilities funding disadvantages should prompt a closer examination of how Pennsylvania distributes education resources.

This is not an argument that charter schools have better buildings. Some do. Others operate in aging or leased facilities with significant maintenance needs. This is also not an argument against investing in district schools.

It is an argument for recognizing that public education extends beyond one system of schools.

As Pennsylvania considers how to address aging school buildings and future capital needs, policymakers have an opportunity to develop a more equitable approach.

That should include a dedicated, sustainable facilities funding stream for brick-and-mortar public charter schools, along with fair access to appropriate state capital and infrastructure programs.

Such an approach would recognize that the need for a safe and effective learning environment follows the student, not the institution.

The debate over Philadelphia’s school buildings should not become another contest between district and charter schools. Both serve public school students. Both have legitimate facilities needs. And both should be part of any serious conversation about educational opportunity.

The Philadelphia Federation of Teachers has helped bring renewed attention to the importance of school facilities.

Now Pennsylvania has an opportunity to broaden that conversation.

A child does not become less deserving of a safe, modern school building because their family chooses a brick-and-mortar public charter school. Nor should a family be punished for the educational choice made on behalf of their child.

The Pennsylvania General Assembly should establish a separate, dedicated facilities funding stream for brick-and-mortar public charter schools to ensure all students are treated fairly.

You May Also Like