A January Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling has already led two districts to cut charter school bus service statewide. Philadelphia’s system isn’t changing; here’s what local families are entitled to, and how to use it.
A Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling handed down in January is reshaping how charter school students get to class in several parts of the state, though not in Philadelphia.
Reporting by Spotlight PA and WITF on August 18 found that Woodland Hills School District near Pittsburgh and the Whitehall Coplay School District in the Lehigh Valley have cut yellow bus service for charter school students and replaced it with public transit passes, a change the ruling now makes legal without prior state approval.
The Court’s January 21 decision in Bell v. Wilkinsburg School District, brought with Propel Charter Schools as a co-plaintiff, interprets Section 1726-A(a) of Pennsylvania’s Charter School Law, which requires districts to provide free transportation to charter students living within the district or within 10 miles of its boundary, under the same conditions the district applies to its own students.
The Court ruled that same conditions governs when a district must provide transportation, not how, meaning a district can lawfully swap buses for transit passes as long as the alternative is free and still meets the law’s distance and safety standards.
The ruling also struck down a lower court requirement that districts seek Pennsylvania Department of Education approval before making that kind of change.
Had the General Assembly intended to require identical transportation between charter and public school students, it could have easily said so, Justice Kevin Dougherty wrote for the Court, according to a summary of the opinion published by the law firm Tucker Arensberg, P.C.
At Woodland Hills, more than 140 students at LIFE Male STEAM Academy have been moved from bus service to Pittsburgh Regional Transit cards. Whitehall Coplay has issued transit authority passes to charter students age 12 and older.
Charter advocates cited by Spotlight PA and WITF say some affected students now face walks of nearly two miles to reach a transit stop.
Philadelphia is not among the districts changing course. The School District of Philadelphia already relies on SEPTA passes, rather than yellow buses, for eligible charter and district students in grades 7 through 12, the same model the Court just upheld.
Because Philadelphia’s system already matches what the ruling permits, the decision changes the district’s legal footing more than its day to day practice.
It forecloses any future argument that charter students are entitled to identical bus service, and it leaves the district free to extend transit pass only transportation to younger students if it chooses to. The district has not announced plans to do so.